The latest issue of Electronic Musician has a quick feature on MXP4 from Musinaut – basically, it’s an audio format that uses multiple takes of individual tracks (like guitar, bass and drums) and allows the artist and listener to construct different versions of the same songs to fit different moods or desires. The tracks can always be different, depending on the elements the artist chooses to put in the songs.
It’s fascinating in concept, and the thought of actually putting the alternate tracks and takes historians and producers have mined over the years is intriguing. The lack of a “true” definitive version is an engaging concept as well – is music like a stew, where nothing shows up in the same order but the overall flavor is the same, or is it like a meticulously prepared and presented plate, with every element ordered and examined by the chef before its released?
My guess is that control freaks (yes, Axl, I’m looking at you) will hate this format and choose to have their songs frozen in time, while others (jam bands, I’m looking at you) will noodle on incessently and use this format as an excuse to throw their work to the masses. I like the idea, but I’m not completely sold because there are sometimes certain elements to the song (the guitar part to Stevie Wonder’s “I Believe,” for example) that I go to for exactly that reason, and not to have them there would lessen the satisfaction of the listening process. On the other hand, well-worn chestnuts could use some refreshing at times, and this is an intriguing way to do it.
To me, the best way to deploy this would be for the artist to offer their mix and make the rest available as added bonuses, letting the audience choose where to go from there. I can’t see it becoming the primary mode of music distribution, but it could become a great diversion for those wanting to delve deeper into an artist’s works.